Theory-Based Digital Interventions to Improve Asthma Self-Management Outcomes: Systematic Review

Journal of Medical Internet Research Vol 20, No 12 (2018): December

Helen J Lycett1*, BSc, MSc Eva M Raebel1*, BSc, MSc, PhD Emilie K Wildman1*, BSc, MSc Jordi Guitart1*, PhD Thomas Kenny1*, BM, MSc-PH(HSM), MFPH, MBA Jon-Paul Sherlock2*, BEng, PhD Vanessa Cooper3*, BSc, MSc, PhD 

ABSTRACT

Background: Asthma is a chronic disease requiring effective self-management to control it and prevent mortality. The use of theory-informed digital interventions promoting asthma self-management is increasing. However, there is limited knowledge concerning how and to what extent psychological theory has been applied to the development of digital interventions, or how using theory impacts outcomes.

Objective: The study aimed to examine the use and application of theory in the development of digital interventions to enhance asthma self-management and to evaluate the effectiveness of theory-based interventions in improving adherence, self-management, and clinical outcomes.

Methods: Electronic databases (CENTRAL, MEDLINE, EMBASE, and PsycINFO) were searched systematically using predetermined terms. Additional studies were identified by scanning references within relevant studies. Two researchers screened titles and abstracts against predefined inclusion criteria; a third resolved discrepancies. Full-text review was undertaken for relevant studies. Those meeting inclusion criteria were assessed for risk of bias using the Cochrane Collaboration tool. The review was conducted in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses statement. Study outcomes were classified as medication adherence, self-management, asthma control, clinical markers of health, quality of life, other quality of life outcomes, and health care utilization. Effectiveness was calculated as an average outcome score based on the study’s reported significance. The Theory Coding Scheme (TCS) was used to establish the extent to which each intervention had applied theory and which theoretical constructs or behavioral determinants were addressed. Associations between TCS scores and asthma outcomes were described within a narrative synthesis.

Results: Fourteen studies evaluating 14 different digital interventions were included in this review. The most commonly cited theories were Social Cognitive Theory, Health Belief Model, and Self-Efficacy Theory. A greater use of theory in the development of interventions was correlated with effective outcomes (r=.657; P=.01): only the 3 studies that met >60% of the different uses of theory assessed by the TCS were effective on all behavioral and clinical outcomes measured. None of the 11 studies that met ≤60% of the TCS criteria were fully effective; however, 3 interventions were partially effective (ie, the intervention had a significant impact on some, but not all, of the outcomes measured). Most studies lacked detail on the theoretical constructs and how they were applied to the development and application of the intervention.

Conclusions: These findings suggest that greater use of theory in the development and application of digital self-management interventions for asthma may increase their effectiveness. The application of theory alone may not be enough to yield a successful intervention, and other factors (eg, the context in which the intervention is used) should be considered. A systematic approach to the use of theory to guide the design, selection, and application of intervention techniques is needed.

J Med Internet Res 2018;20(12):e293

doi:10.2196/jmir.9666

(You must be logged in to add and reply comments)

Interasma on Twitter

Interasma RT @EAACI_HQ: A promising new diagnostic assay able to identify different phenotypes and degree of #CMA #foodallergy #Allergy_journal https…
5hreplyretweetfavorite
Interasma RT @AllergyEaaci: Delayed drug hypersensitivity to bortezomib: desensitization and tolerance to its analogue carfilzomib. Corresponding Aut…
5hreplyretweetfavorite
Interasma RT @worldallergy: WAO Tweeted Times https://t.co/1tA4uy3LDq - top stories by @EAACI_HQ
5hreplyretweetfavorite
5hreplyretweetfavorite

Editor: Juan C. Ivancevich, MD

Copyright © Interasma 2003-2017  •  Terms of Use  •  Privacy Policy  •  Contact Us  •  Sitemap

Powered by FREI SA

InterAsma